Novated lease vs car loan: how they compare
Buying a car for personal use? Here's how a novated lease and a standard car loan differ, explained in plain English.
If you're buying a car for personal use, a novated lease and a standard car loan are two common ways to pay for it. They work very differently. This guide explains how each one works so you can see the differences. It's general information only, not advice.
How each one works
- Car loan: you borrow the money and own the car from day one. You repay from your after tax pay, and the lender holds security over the car until the loan is paid.
- Novated lease: a three way agreement between you, your employer and a lease provider. Repayments, and often running costs, come out of your pay before tax. The provider can be your employer's preferred one or an external provider you choose, but your employer still has to agree to the arrangement and process the deductions.
Side by side
| Novated lease | Car loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Provider owns it until the residual is paid | You own it from day one |
| Payments | From your pay, mostly pre tax | From your bank account, after tax |
| Running costs | Can be bundled into the deduction | Paid separately |
| Employer | Must agree to the arrangement | Not involved |
| End of term | Residual payment (ATO guidelines) | Optional balloon, or none |
| Changing jobs | Lease can move to a new employer if they agree | No effect |
| Tax | Pre tax deductions; eligible EVs may be FBT exempt | No tax benefit on a private car |
Things people often weigh up
Many people look at how secure their job is, whether they plan to keep the car to the end of the term, whether the car is electric, and whether they're comfortable with a residual payment at the end. A novated lease relies on your employer and your payroll. A car loan doesn't, and works whether you're an employee, a contractor or self employed.
A worked example
Here's a $50,000 car over 5 years at an example rate of 8%, before fees and before any tax saving. A 5 year novated lease has a residual of about 28% of the car's value, which is around $14,065.
| Monthly repayment | Final payment | Total paid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Car loan, no balloon | $1,014 | None | $60,830 |
| Novated lease, 28% residual | $822 | $14,065 | $63,409 |
The lease has the lower monthly repayment, and the loan has the lower total, because the residual keeps part of the balance owing for longer. Any tax saving on a novated lease (and GST saved on running costs) depends on your own income and the car, and provider fees also affect the full cost. The figures above are examples only, not rates we're offering.
Questions worth asking
- What's the total cost over the full term under each option, including fees and the final residual?
- What's the interest rate, and is there a separate monthly admin fee?
- What happens to the lease if I leave my job or my employer changes the benefit?
- What's included in the running costs budget, and is any unused amount refunded?
Want to know what you could be approved for?
Free, no obligation quote. No impact on your credit file.
This guide is general information only and doesn't take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice. Talk to us about your situation, and to your accountant about tax.